My partner has been diving deep into shadow work as part of his spiritual journey, and he’s searching for a tarot deck that’s genuinely unsettling.
Not just gothic or Halloween-themed, but something that makes you feel uncomfortable when you handle it. I’ve looked through the Gothic tarot list and the dark Tarot cards. There are some good ones there, but I’m wondering if anyone has any ideas for… creepy.
He already has the Ghosts and Spirits deck and Darkness of Light, but they’re not intense enough for what he needs.
He says the darker imagery helps him access parts of himself that lighter decks can’t reach - it’s like how some of us need to face our deepest fears to transform them into growth. Has anyone worked with a deck that actually made them shiver? Something raw and confrontational that stays with you after a reading?
I’m trying to surprise him, but I’m struggling to find anything that fits what he’s describing.
11 Likes
Deepen Your Tarot Practice Beyond the Cards
Finding meaningful tarot discussions and authentic guidance can be surprisingly difficult. Discover a space where your questions are welcomed and your intuitive growth is celebrated: Start Your Journey
Hard one! Since “creepy” is going to be a little bit subjective for everyone, I think you’re probably in the right place with the dark and gothic lists already.
I consider myself pretty open to the spiritual world and… this one would give me the creeps more than anything (I’m not good with ghosts).
But if this is the one he already has there’s a darker asthetic ghost deck too.
I think both of these would creep me out too much to work with them… so I hope that helps 
/edit: I’m assuming this doesn’t count as creepy? Just found it as well but probably not what you’re looking for.
The deviant moon deck gives me pretty… unsettling vibes, and I know I’m not the only one. The stretched figures and carnival-like art stick in my head and I know it’s used for some deeper shadow work as well.
I 
this thoughtful gift idea! Shadow work alongside uncomfortable imagery can be powerful. We need to sit with what unsettles us to understand why it has that effect.
I do agree, Deviant Moon Tarot might work for him. The figures are distorted and there’s something genuinely off about them that gets under your skin.
Another option is the Dark Mirror Oracle - technically not tarot, but the artwork is deeply disturbing in a way that forces you to look at parts of yourself you’d rather avoid.
The Bosch Tarot, based on Hieronymus Bosch’s paintings, has this medieval hellscape quality that feels visceral. Some readers find it too chaotic but that chaos can break through mental barriers.
If he wants something that leaves a lasting impression, look into the Tarot of the Flesh by Victoria Iva. The imagery deals with decay and transformation in ways that most decks won’t touch. Fair warning, though. Once you work with truly dark decks, they tend to change how you read everything else.
The I Am deck and Kabbalistic Visions give me the chills.
Their imagery just doesn’t sit right with me, and I end up tense when I try to read with them. I usually reach for lighter decks instead.
The Hermetic Tarot got to me, too. Those black and white illustrations with all the occult symbolism were too intense for daily readings. My grandmother used to say some decks choose their people, and some people need gentler guides. I ended up giving mine to someone who connected better with that heavy esoteric stuff.
The medieval engravings and astrological symbols felt dark compared to my usual RWS deck.
Everyone’s drawn to different art and symbolism, so here are some other decks that might work for you both.
I agree about Deviant Moon, the surreal artwork really brings out the shadow side of each card. Some people do find it creepy, and I won’t use it with younger querants; however, I really enjoy the deck for its quirkiness too. So I don’t really struggle with it at all.
If you like contemporary stuff with traditional structure, check out the Modern Witch Tarot.
The Wild Unknown has these stark animal illustrations that a lot of people find intuitive. For something more nature-based, that could be a good fit.
If you want historical depth, Marseille decks have that classic feel. Just know they’re pip-based instead of fully illustrated. The Mystic Mondays has a modern look with geometric patterns and bold colors.
For anyone into Wicca or goddess energy, Dreams of Gaia incorporates those themes while still being accessible for general readings. What kind of artwork do you usually like? That might help narrow things down.
Creepy doesn’t need blood and gore.
The most unsettling decks have this weird, empty feeling, like hollow-eyed figures staring at you with muted colors everywhere. Carnival at the End of the World and Tarot of the Abyss both have that quiet, creeping unease that sticks with you way longer than jump scares would.
Hope you find what you’re looking for in these darker decks.
Your partner using shadow work decks sounds pretty intense. The darker decks can be more meaningful when you set the mood - like only using one candle when you pull cards. You don’t need to use a darker deck for this stuff, but if he resonates with them, then lean into it.
I picked up the Maleficium Tarot last month and honestly wish I hadn’t. The artwork is beautiful, but there’s something about it that makes my stomach turn every time I use it. Perfect for what your partner wants, though - it might push you into spaces you don’t want to go otherwise. I personally don’t like decks like these.
Has he tried just using a “normal” deck for the same readings? You could get one of the popular decks that you can work with, too, and he can try something a bit different.
The Nicoletta Ceccoli Tarot has these childlike dolls with hollow eyes that really tap into something primal. The Santa Muerte deck gets misunderstood as just being dark and morbid, but there’s more depth to it than that.
Has your partner considered modifying an existing deck? I took a regular RWS and painted over sections with black ink, adding my own symbols. Sometimes creating the darkness yourself makes it more personal and effective for shadow work.
Plus you control exactly how intense it gets.
The Murder of Crows Tarot gets a 9/10 from me for being genuinely creepy.
Each card has crows in different stages of decay and transformation, the Death card shows a crow skeleton putting itself back together. The cardstock is kinda thin though, maybe 7/10. Speaking of thin, when I used this deck for shadow work last winter, things got pretty intense. The veil between worlds felt like tissue paper.
Check out Caitlin McCarthy’s work if you haven’t already. They created the Antique Anatomy Tarot, and their other projects deal with medical imagery and death in ways that feel raw and real.
Not a horror movie, scary but unsettling on a deeper level.
